Tuesday, 10 February 2026

Telling signs

When you begin to get subtle hints that your presence (or absence) does not make a difference...

You know, in India a person is measured not by the person he or she is but by what job, what position he or she holds... the Ministers and the Babus have the right of way everywhere, also cricketers and filmstars, I guess.  Of course if you are a university or IIT professor, it is not so bad either... but give it up, and say you are bekar, or that you are self-employed, or that you have retired, ... and slowly you begin to notice the difference. I guess the first time I noticed was when some people at RGU asked me to come and give a talk... I agreed and even started preparing for it. But then one of the organisers asked me for my institutional affiliation and I said I didn't have one anymore. I never heard back from them! I'm not sure when I have actually last spoken (or been invited to speak) at an event that I have not organised myself. Not that I want to speak anywhere but slowly the realisation seeps in.

You feel it in small ways -- when people don't invite you to events is one thing, but when you go along anyways out of sheer interest, and meet people, mostly younger academics all full of pep and ambition, they are nice and polite, and say that they have been meaning to call you and that we should meet up and that they would really like to talk about their research with you, and that they will definitely get back by the next week, but then, that is the last time you ever hear from them! Not that I mind...

I guess people who retire from high places also have the same feeling, or perhaps that is the reason why the Babus on retirement, find something else to do that keep them from feeling being made redundant.... And a dear friend of mine who is a retired academic tells me how some of her former students, who used to surround her constantly while she was their teacher and guide, suddenly began to find excuses for not being able to visit her, or to drop by once in a long while, even when they were going past their home, once she retired. 

Sometimes it can even be amusing or irritating ... depending on how you decide to look at it... Suppose you are going to see a performance or a play... the first two or three rows have 'reserved' written boldly  on the seats so that velas like me are encouraged to find a seat after the fourth row. I don't mind, but then even senior citizens who have problems with walking up steps to the rear etc are not spared. Sometimes even if they agree to allow the senior person to sit in front, they require the younger relative/attendant to sit many rows back which then creates other problems for the senior citizen. Of course Babus and VIPs are welcome to make their ayahs, maids and security personnel sit on the first row sofas if  their masters don't mind their so doing. It is hilarious. Funniest when after all the guests have arrived and the event is about to start, the front rows remain empty and then they have to request the same people who they shooed to the back earlier to please move to the front!

Just recently something weird happened. There was a seminar at Cotton. The big shots were in the front two rows, I was on the third. It so happened that I was directly behind the two biggest shots of the event but there was an aisle separating the two -- very convenient for the many still ambitious and need-to-be-seen academics who then, without so much as a by-your-leave, although all of them knew me, decided to take turns at standing in the aisle between the two greats, to get their photos taken! That there is no photo of me at the event is besides the point... but the steady rush of people to the 'photo point' between the two biggies directly in front of my nose blocking my view was annoying.

Have you noticed that there are some people who do not go to meetings and events 'just to listen'? Some are so stuck up that they don't go if their names do not appear on the invitation card.  And then I think of the likes of Prof. Sanjib Baruah from Bard College New York, who will arrive anywhere to hear someone speak, if the topic interests him. Of course if you have attained the level of a Hiren Gohain or a Himanta Biswa Sarma, you have to speak wherever you go, but much 'smaller' people, in fact, even some young beginners, don't think they should go to any event simply to listen, that they have nothing more to learn from anyone, that it is time for them to give their gyan to others, and so on.  Some of them have huge numbers of followers on social media, so much so that they get offended if idiots like me fail to recognise them somewhere. The other way round, when people have to introduce me, the only introductions they often find for me are either via my parents, or via my German connection! So much so that you would think that, without these two, I would have no identity at all... Perhaps I don't, but it bugs me that the fact that I simply happened to live in Germany for a few years is considered to be more important than everything else that I might have ever done before or after!

And of course the most annoying thing about me that really puts people off is the fact that I actually tell the organisers that I can't stand the endlessly long formal beginnings (and endings) of meetings -- with some music, a formal welcome address, felicitation of the many guests, then quite a number of long and winding speeches by people who hold positions of power and authority but who have nothing to do with the subject of the meeting before they actually get down the real business of the day! By then, more often than not, more than one hour has gone by and the meeting has not yet really begun...! Given the fact that most meetings in the city begin at least half an hour late, for me, it is almost time to leave, before they can even come to the point. And sometimes I do walk out. The endings with the vote of thanks etc etc are often also long but usually I do not last that long...Later, the organisers seem to agree with me in private about how so much time was wasted but then on social media and other outlets they are gushing with praise of the many very important people 'who spared their valuable time despite their very busy schedules to be with them and to encourage them with their wise and significant words of guidance and support!' My foot!

Soon I would have gained a reputation as a ill-tempered impatient old hag who has the audacity to make unsolicited unfavourable comments on events and programmes where no one really wanted her to be present in the first place. What a fall that will be... and quite deserved too! Thank goodness for Sabhaghar and Addaghar... at least no one can banish me from there, and in these two spaces, nobody can stop me from doing things done my way... 

Read more...

Wednesday, 31 December 2025

Bidding farewell to a troubled year

2025 was not easy, by many counts. The world was imploding at various fronts, there were wars and famines and natural calamities, the powerful few were playing their dirty games to keep the rest of the world out, common people were suffering yet powerless to change their fate; at a personal level, 2025 is the year when my dear friend Tithi left for another world and left me stunned and unable to cope.  It was also the year when I was forced to admit that although I have a strong and healthy body, even I can fall sick seriously; it was also the year I felt very strongly blessed by the healing power of the love and affection of my many wonderful friends.
Read more...

Monday, 8 September 2025

Sishugram of my memory and of my dreams

Sishugram, a Girls Home that I help to run in North Guwahati is celebrating its Golden Jubilee this year. Established in 1975, Sishugram has been part of my life right from its inception. In this article, meant for publication in the Golden Jubilee Souvenir, I chart out the broad outlines of my association with it. This is no report of the Managing Trustee. Nor is it some kind of a factual recounting of milestones and achievements. It is just a rambling recounting of my sometimes close, and sometimes distant association with Sishugram for almost the entire fifty years of its existence. For context, my mother Smti Renuka Devi Barkataki was one of the founding trustees of the Sishugram Trust and was associated with it since its inception in 1975 till her death in 2017. At the outset, I pay homage to her memory and to the memory of her close friend and associate Smti Minoti Chowdhury; both of them were very closely associated with Sishugram, both are no longer here today to see Sishugram attain this golden milestone. May they guide us, if only in spirit, also in the years to come.


Read more...

Tuesday, 26 August 2025

4. What after finishing school? Higher Education/Vocational training in Germany

Written with inputs from Zeynep Acharya, Petra Varma and many others; and also from official internet sources

In a certain sense it can be said that the decision for what a child in Germany will go on to become in life is already decided in the 5th grade with the choice of which type of secondary school that child joins; of which there are essentially three kinds -- the Hauptschule, the Realschule and the Gymnasium. Let us take a closer look at what choices students have after finishing one of these three forms of secondary school.


Read more...

3. Some further aspects of the German school system

Written jointly with Zeynep Acharya and with inputs from various official internet sites

This is the third part of a series of essays on the German school system, the first was the school through the eyes of a student, the second was the school system through the eyes of a teacher and this third part is about some important points that have not been mentioned so far.


Read more...

2. The German School System – A View from the Teacher's Room

Written jointly with Zeynep Acharya and from her view point, with inputs from various official internet sites

I have been a teacher in Germany for many years, and during this time I have accompanied children and young people at very different stages of their educational journey. As a teacher, I face a class full of young people every day, each of whom brings their own unique story. When I look at our school system, I see a complex web of opportunities, challenges, and traditions. Let me begin by saying that what I describe below from my own experiences in Hamburg is only a representative example – Education is a state subject in Germany and hence the details of the education system vary slightly from state to state.


Read more...

1. Between the Blackboard and Dreams – Lena's Journey Through the German School System

The German school system through the eyes of a student Lena. Written with the help of Zeynep Acharya, who teaches in Hamburg, with inputs from various official internet sites

Lena sits at her classroom window, gazing out at the gray schoolyard. It's her last day at the Realschule (Intermediate school) in Hamburg, and while her classmates talk loudly about the upcoming summer holidays, Lena reflects on her journey – a journey that has led her through the many facets of the German school system.


Read more...

Tuesday, 8 July 2025

Tithi, my strong but silent friend, is now still forever


Her trademark smile: 18.6.24
A tribute to my dear friend Tithi (Monjari Barooah) who passed on the 3rd July 2025, after a 14-month struggle with a deadly disease.
Read more...

Friday, 13 June 2025

Childhood: a carefree romp that didn’t last

A random account of some events of my childhood... I began to write this piece because I wanted to send it to Teresa Rahman as part of her series on childhood memories in the Thumprint Northeast. But it turned out to be a very therapeutic exercise as well as the news of the horrible aircraft disaster in Ahmedabad came in. It might sound self-indulgent but it kept me from sinking... 

My childhood was mostly happy, and spent mainly at three places, Guwahati, Delhi and Shillong. I was born in Delhi as my mother, Renuka Devi Barkataki, was a young parliamentarian at that time. But whenever my mother needed to go anywhere, since my absentminded and rather impractical father, Munin Barkotoki, could not be trusted with such things, I was left with my aunt, my Jethima, in Shillong, who ran a full house with six kids of her own. The first time I was left there I was barely a few months old – Ma was selected to be part of a parliamentary delegation to the US. She was gone for more than a month.  When she returned, I did not recognize my mother anymore and refused to go back with her. I am told I was put in the care of two very nice kongs, first the very pretty Kong Cross and after her Kong Cheni, but I have no real memory of them. 

Read more...

Wednesday, 30 April 2025

A lesser known version of Rajasthan


The most touristy thing we did on this trip
Our annual road trip this time was to  Rajasthan -- yes, it was in Jan-Feb this time and  not in November and yes, it was much shorter than the usual three weeks, we did what we could, but at the end of the two weeks we had covered 3342 kilometers which is about the same if not a little more than what we had done in our annual forays lasting about three weeks in previous years. We drove a lot but all that driving was enough only to discover a very tiny part of that large, beautiful, colourful and extremely attractive state. 

There were essentially three cities we planned our trip around this time -- Bikaner, Jaisalmer and Jodhpur. But we also got to experience some parts of Rajasthan that tourists normally do not have time for. We saw many imposing but abandoned hawelis, huge but deserted villages, breathtakingly beautiful architecture and exquisite frescoes, pretty lakes, vast desert landscapes and much more... Also, it was the first time I felt that while on a road trip, the journey itself is what was special, much more than the destination. Looking out of the window of our Kia Seltos into the endless desert sand dunes and the scruffy green-gold landscape filled with low bushes and thorny shrubs, one could experience not just the magnificence of it all, but also the pettiness and meaninglessness of so many of our earthly ambitions...

Read more...